Lesson 2 · 20 min
Close packing: ABAB and ABCABC
Stack equal spheres layer by layer like oranges: the two choices for the third layer give hexagonal and cubic close packing, both 74 % full, with tetrahedral and octahedral holes between the layers.
In this lesson
- Build ABAB (hcp) and ABCABC (ccp) stackings layer by layer and say how they differ
- Derive the close-packed filling π/(3√2) = 74 % and compare it with bcc and simple cubic
- Give the number of tetrahedral and octahedral holes per sphere and the largest radius each can hold
- Find the close-packed layers inside the face-centred cubic cell
Oranges on a market stall are always stacked into pyramids: each orange in an upper layer sits in a dimple between three below. In 1611 Kepler conjectured that this arrangement, filling about 74 % of space, is the densest possible for equal spheres. The “obvious” claim was proved only in 1998, by Thomas Hales with computer assistance, and fully machine-checked in 2017. The atoms of most metallic elements are stacked in just this way.
One layer, two layers, and the third
First pack equal spheres as tightly as possible on a plane: each sphere touches 6 others in a triangular net — call it layer A. Above A lie two sets of hollows, B and C. Either can cradle the second layer, but only one set at a time — neighbouring hollows are too close to hold two spheres.
With the second layer on B, the third has two choices:
- straight above A, giving ABAB…, hexagonal close packing (hcp), as in Mg, Zn and Ti;
- over C, giving ABCABC…, cubic close packing (ccp), as in Cu, Al and Au.
Both have a layer spacing of (with the sphere diameter), both fill 74.05 % of space, and in both every sphere has 12 touching neighbours: 6 in its own layer, 3 above and 3 below.
Predict first
Layers A and B are in place. If the third layer goes over C instead of back over A, what happens to the packing fraction?
Pick an answer and lock it in before you look. A wrong guess teaches more than no guess.
- packing fraction
- sphere diameter
- area per sphere in the triangular net
- spacing between neighbouring layers
Cubic close packing is face-centred cubic
Why is cubic close packing also called face-centred cubic? Look along the body diagonal of the fcc cell (the [111] direction): the atomic layers perpendicular to it are exactly the triangular close-packed nets, repeating A, B, C. The cubic cell and the ABC stacking are two descriptions of one structure — the first is convenient for calculation, the second shows why it is so dense. hcp has no cubic symmetry; its cell is hexagonal, with an ideal axial ratio .
Holes: room for smaller spheres
Even close packing leaves 26 % of space empty, in two kinds of hole:
- tetrahedral holes, enclosed by 3 spheres below and 1 above (or the reverse), hold a sphere of radius ; there are 2 per sphere;
- octahedral holes, enclosed by 3 spheres below and 3 above, hold a sphere of radius ; there is 1 per sphere.
Many ionic crystals are “large anions close-packed, small cations in the holes”: NaCl is in ccp with in every octahedral hole; zinc blende ZnS is in ccp with in half the tetrahedral holes; swap the roles and fluorite is in ccp with in every tetrahedral hole. The numbers 0.225 and 0.414 return in the next lesson as radius ratios.
Worked example
The packing fraction of body-centred cubic
Sodium is body-centred cubic. Treating its atoms as touching hard spheres, find the packing fraction.
| Structure | CN | Packing fraction | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| Simple cubic | 6 | α-Po | |
| Body-centred cubic | 8 | Na, Fe, W | |
| Face-centred cubic (ccp) | 12 | Cu, Al, Au | |
| Hexagonal close-packed | 12 | Mg, Ti | |
| Diamond | 4 | C, Si, Ge |
Concept check
Which unit cell describes ABCABC… stacking?
Try the calculation
In a close-packed array of ions (radius 181 pm), what is the largest cation radius that fits an octahedral hole?
Key takeaways
- Equal spheres pack into triangular nets; the second layer sits on B or C, and the third layer’s choice gives hcp (ABAB) or ccp = fcc (ABCABC).
- Both close packings fill π/(3√2) = 74 % of space with coordination number 12.
- Each sphere has 2 tetrahedral holes (room for 0.225r) and 1 octahedral hole (0.414r); many ionic crystals are “anions packed, cations in the holes”.
- Body-centred cubic fills 68 %, simple cubic 52 % and diamond 34 %: lower coordination, looser packing.
Data and references
- A. R. West, Basic Solid State Chemistry, 2nd ed. (Wiley, 1999), Ch. 1.
- P. Atkins, T. Overton, J. Rourke, M. Weller, F. Armstrong, Shriver & Atkins’ Inorganic Chemistry, 5th ed. (OUP, 2010), Ch. 3.
- T. C. Hales et al., “A formal proof of the Kepler conjecture”, Forum of Mathematics, Pi 5, e2 (2017).
- W. M. Haynes (ed.), CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics, 97th ed. (CRC Press, 2016) — lattice parameters of Mg, Zn, Cd.